• You're one step from joining Canning Forum – Home Preserving, Pickling & Fermentation Techniques.
    Create a free account to post, follow threads, and never miss an update.  Sign up free →

Best tomato varieties for making salsa and spaghetti sause

LidLocker

New member
Joined
May 3, 2025
Messages
4
I'm excited to start growing tomatoes this season, particularly for canning salsa and spaghetti sauce. I'm wondering if you have any favorite varieties that work really well and taste great for sauces?

I keep seeing Roma and San Marzano come up in conversations, but I'd love to know what has worked best for you personally. What are your go-to choices?
 
I'm excited to start growing tomatoes this season, particularly for canning salsa and spaghetti sauce. I'm wondering if you have any favorite varieties that work really well and taste great for sauces?

I keep seeing Roma and San Marzano come up in conversations, but I'd love to know what has worked best for you personally. What are your go-to choices?
To add to @BOLT over here about which his recommendations are also dear to me, I think you should also try Opalka and Viva Italia. Really good ones!
 
I agree with the above. By far, for sauces the Roma and San Marzano, and Amish paste tomatoes are best. They are low water percentage compared to others. I blanch, pull skins off, blend in blender, put through food mill, then can the sauce. I leave about 10% of them with skins and seeds and chop them up in my jars to give texture to my sauce. Wasting nothing, I take the skins and put them on my dehydrator overnight, then grind them into "tomato powder" which I put in large spice shakers. It can be added to any recipe to thicken and give a richer tomato flavor.
 
I love hearing about all these selections—it takes me back to my first real canning season a couple of years ago. I began with San Marzanos, since my aunt always raved about them, but then a neighbor gave me some Amish Paste seedlings, and they absolutely stole the spotlight. They're so meaty and sweet, making them perfect for rich sauces. This year, I'm really tempted to try Opalka too after hearing all the positive reviews. Has anyone else tried dehydrating the skins like @SlowCookerPro? That idea of making tomato powder is just brilliant!
 
I don't get hung up on which tomato goes in the sauce. We grow a variety of "sauce tomatoes, and slicing tomatoes with 1 or 2 plants of cherry tomatoes. As the season gets in full swing, we pick anything that is ripe. I put aside a few "slicing tomatoes" for sandwiches, etc. and some cherry tomatoes for salads. Any surplus gets thrown in the sauce with the Amish paste, San Marzano, and Romas. I don't have a "favorite" for sauce, each year it's a blend of what we have growing.
I hate waste, so I dehydrate the skins as I get a chance. Since I can around 36 Qts of sauce each season, I don't waste a lot of time peeling the skins off each tomato. After I blanch and cool them, I give a tug on the skins to try to remove them before running them through my food mill. Not taking the skins off results in having to clean the mill much more often so it makes sense to remove as many skins as possible before running the tomatoes through the food mill. The skins that come off easily get put in a separate bowl. When I get time, I spray the dehydrator with cooking spray, and lay them all out. I have silicone inserts for the dehydrator so I use them. They dry very quickly, a few hours. You could use an oven on low also. When done, they are paper-like and I smash them into my spice grinder. I pack them in until I can't get any more in, then pulse it 3 or 4 times. They turn to powder. I use a funnel and dump it into a large empty spice shaker. By the end of the season, it's full. I shake tomato powder over roasts, add it to soups, anything that would benefit from a richer tomato flavor. It lasts in the spice cabinet for a year no problem.
We grow so many tomatoes, that I also end up making tomato paste. I put the excess tomato sauce into a large crock pot with the a wooden spoon under the lid so the steam can escape and slow cook it on low. You need to stir it every so often, and I usually leave it overnight and then keep an eye on it the next day. When the water evaporates out, It is very thick and I put it into extra-large silicone ice-cube trays and freeze them overnight. I then pop them out of the trays into gallon ziplock bags. and put them in the freezer. Each cube is aprox. half-a-can of tomato paste which is perfect b/c many recipies call for only 1/2 can.
 
Back
Top